Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

A Key Change for Mobile Phones

Continued from page 1

By Wade Roush

Friday, May 18, 2007

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

In contrast to expensive Treos and BlackBerrys, phones with the extra keys for the Fastap system are only slightly more expensive to manufacture than traditional mobile phones are, according to Levy. Alltel and Telus are offering them to customers at subsidized prices similar to those for their other phones--$9.99, with a long-term contract, in Alltel's case.

Superimposing alphabetic keys on a numeric keypad may sound like a simple idea, but Levy says that some software trickery was required to make it work in practice. The problem is that the Fastap design fits more than twice as many keys into the same area as a traditional keypad. Raising the letter keys gives users tactile feedback that helps them distinguish the letter keys from the number keys. But occasionally, users who intend to press number keys may accidentally press letter keys first, or roll their fingers from number keys onto letter keys.

When adjacent letter and number keys are pressed in quick sequence, algorithms programmed into the Fastap phones always give priority to the lower number keys. Similar algorithms deal with cases in which the users' fingers roll from a number key onto a letter key, or in which two diagonal letter keys are pressed together. Because the software automatically corrects such fumbles, the "touch area" available around each key is effectively the same as that of keys on a laptop computer.

On average, experienced Fastap users write text messages three times faster than triple typers do, Levy claims. He says that users adapt quickly to the alphabetical order of the Fastap keyboard, even if they're accustomed to the QWERTY keyboards of computers and BlackBerry-type devices.

Levy says that Digit Wireless is in negotiations with more mobile-phone manufacturers and carriers, and he expects that Fastap phones will be available soon in Mexico, South America, Europe, and Asia. The company is also exploring alternate bi-level keypad layouts that would accommodate larger alphabets, such as Cyrillic (with 32 letters), Thai (49), and Hindi (60). In those cases, users might have to do some double typing to select the intended letter, Levy says. "But if you go from an average of eight taps down to two, there is still a huge benefit."

Comments

  • New keyboard for mobiles
    I cannot understand why the article keeps referring to triple-typing.

    Hasn't the author or even Mr Levy heard of predictive text on Nokia phones and the T9 facility on others that permits the user to simply type the word as it is spelt? For example, to type 'norm', only 6676 needs to be pressed.

    The phone then permits the user to cycle thru the various combinations if the first one displayed is not what is required. As above, 6676 also spells 'morn' - to get either the user only needs to press the * key to get the options.

    The user thus needs to triple-type only words that are not in the dictionary.

    I believe its not the phone keypad but the QWERTY layout that really slows things down, and it amazes me that it is touted as a great feature in PDAs etc.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    deejay
    05/18/2007
    Posts:23
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: New keyboard for mobiles
      And no mention of the suretype system used on RIM Blackberry handsets such as the Pearl - with only 2 letters per key and an excellent predictive system -

      Everyone forgets that the QWERTY keyboard was designed to slow down manual typists in the 19th/20th century to stop manual typewriter keys sticking together - the DVORAK simplified method would make more sense - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dvorak_Simplified_Keyboard
      Rate this comment: 12345

      david.brady@...
      05/18/2007
      Posts:1
      • Re: New keyboard for mobiles
        "Everyone forgets that the QWERTY keyboard was designed to slow down manual typists "

        That's actually not quite true.

        The only studies that Dvorak's keyboard was faster were done by Dvorak or that cite Dvorak who was trying to sell his own keyboards.

        Liebowitz and Margolis find that Qwerty was selected in a marketplace of various competing standards, and perhaps won out because it was the keyboard used by a winner of a typing competition. Some suggest that its odd design allows for better flow.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        hobs
        05/18/2007
        Posts:1
        Avg Rating:
        1/5
    • Re: New keyboard for mobiles
      You can't understand why the article refers to triple typing?  The article refers to it because that is what the majority of people do when they text message.  Why complain so much when a good article is read?  The scope of the article is to talk about a new innovation, which it does very well.  It is not meant as an exhaustive survey on all of the different ways people type in their mobile phones.   Please be more positive in your feedback in the future.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      pratekya
      05/18/2007
      Posts:4
      Avg Rating:
      2/5
  • Patent
    Anyone know which patents this is covered under?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    sykessler
    05/18/2007
    Posts:1
    • Re: Patent
      The patent number is 5,612,690.  You can get a PDF copy of the patent at www.pat2pdf.org.  An application was filed in 1993, but a patent did not issue until 1997. 

      Because the patent was filed before 1995, the term will probably last until 1997+17.

      I have an opinion about the scope of the patent, i.e., the claims, but will save you from it. 

      Regards.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      delafield
      05/18/2007
      Posts:5
      • Your opinion interests me ! Re: Patent
        Can you write it down  ?
        or can you email to me  ?
        lgs@tikilabs.com
        Are you a specialist of disruptive entry solutions ?

        Could we speak ? Larry +336 7419 9133
        Rate this comment: 12345

        tikilgs
        05/24/2007
        Posts:2
  • A Clever Innovation......
    ...or re-adaptation that's [a] already proved itself by increased messaging and [b] will draw the usual number of complaints and resentments.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    rttedrow
    05/18/2007
    Posts:46
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • Micro Qwerty will win but ...
    Micro Qwerty will win, because, for a given kind of keyboard, you have many choices of phones...

    but ... some people will have a try to Fastap
    simple users doing mostly voice calls, not knowing Qwerty and willing to add SMS ...

    It is a niche proposition.

    If the ARPU generated was so much bigger than with other similar phones, operators would subsidize much more than others ...

    And this keyboard does not solve the touch typing
    (not looking to the keys but your buddies) probleme all phone keyboards have.

    When you leave your office it is to meet people, listen, look, move ... not looking intrusively to your keys...

    see www.tikilabs.com for a real future ...
    Rate this comment: 12345

    tikilgs
    05/19/2007
    Posts:2

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Malleable Maps, Artistic Robots and Bubble Interfaces
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.