Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

HDTV over the Internet

Companies are finding ways to stream high-definition TV signals over the Web. Could the technology make low-quality video at sites like YouTube a distant memory?

By Wade Roush

Tuesday, August 29, 2006

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

The Internet is about to deliver beautiful high-definition TV to your PC. Matrixstream of Vancouver, British Columbia, has introduced technology for streaming real-time, interactive HDTV signals to home computers over the public Internet.

Today's PCs are more than capable of decoding and displaying both standard-definition TV (with a resolution of 480 pixels vertically and from 640 to 720 pixels horizontally) and high-definition TV (720 to 1,080 pixels vertically and 1,280 to 1,920 pixels horizontally). Indeed, media organizations have been using digital video processors and the Internet's underlying communications standard to send TV signals over private networks for years -- a practice called Internet Protocol TV, or IPTV.

Still, it may be hard to imagine the Web offering high-definition video, which has as many as 1,080 lines of vertical resolution, when sites like CNN.com and YouTube still deliver TV pictures at a measly 320 by 240 pixels of resolution. Delivering HDTV signals has always been the province of cable and satellite TV companies and over-the-air broadcasters, all of which own or license private, dedicated, high-bandwidth channels to get their shows into consumers' living rooms.

The challenge is how to get high-definition TV signals into a computer, short of hooking it directly to a subscription cable line. One solution is to translate a TV signal into standard Internet Protocol packets -- IPTV -- and send it to homes via broadband Internet connections, which are increasingly common. As of March 2006, 42 percent of U.S. homes had broadband Internet connections via DSL or cable modems, according to the Pew Internet and American Life Project.

But HDTV is a big bandwidth hog. Transmitting HDTV signals in real time, using the telecommunications industry's usual MPEG-2 compression standard for moving images, means sending data at 18 to 20 megabits per second (Mbps). The typical consumer DSL connection, by contrast, delivers data at only 1.5 to 3 Mbps, and the fastest cable-modem connections top out at 5 Mbps.

And even a 5-Mbps Internet connection isn't guaranteed to operate that fast all the time: engineers call the Internet a "best effort" network, meaning data packets are delivered as quickly as the myriad bottlenecks in data centers, the Internet backbone, and the last-mile connections into homes allow. Hence the long wait while your PC's media player software is "buffering" an audio or video download.

Matrixstream, founded in 1999 and headquartered in Vancouver, British Columbia, claims to have found a way around these difficulties. Like other companies in the video-processing business, it has adopted a new compression format, called MPEG-4 Part 10/H.264, which allows high-quality video transmissions at less than half the bit rate of MPEG-2. "But it's not just a compression issue -- it's an Internet transport issue," says Jack Chung, Matrixstream's chief technology officer.

According to Chung, Matrixstream's engineers developed a system of video servers that encode and encrypt a video signal, then send it to a special player program on the user's PC, using proprietary buffering and error-correction techniques that compensate for Internet bottlenecks. In this way, Matrixstream can transmit a DVD-quality TV signal at 1.5 Mbps and a high-definition signal at 2.5 Mbps -- well within the capacity of a cable-modem connection.

Comments

  • HDTV over internet
    I agree with the article!  We at Earthflix.com have been posting HD online since February in what we think is the first online HD series, California P.I..  This goofy, campy comedy is offered in
    half 1080 size, 960 X 540 using H.264.  We have  a full screen size 1440 X 810 we're testing.  Every Tuesday we've been posting our show (we're on episode 29 now) along with a smaller 480 X 270 and ipod versions.  We have a few other short  HD videos on our HD page.  We believe in HD over the internet is the way to go.  Your computer screen is already HD capable!
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Robert
    08/29/2006
    Posts:1
    • Re: HDTV over internet
      nifty.

      what are the file sizes?

      edit: rock. i checked out your site, and doing the math, given a high speed 600KB/s download rate (which is usually where i max out at home), the download time is the same as the play length for the 960x540 version, so there wouldnt be much buffer-time at all.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      brunascle
      08/29/2006
      Posts:68
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • Standard resolution IPTV
    SaskTel, a telco in Saskatchewan, Canada has had IPTV available to subscribers for 3 years.  As long as the house is less than 1km from an exchange connected with fibre-optics, their ADSL service has a bandwith of about 8Mbaud.  Each TV set-top box takes 3Mbaud (you can have up to 2 set-top boxes per  phone line, so you can watch 2 different TV shows at the same time), leaving at least 1.5MBaud for a conventional high speed internet connection.

    The service is pretty good, basically equivalent to standard digital cable service, with artifacts from the MPEG compression showing up a couple of times an hour (or maybe the software fills in the blanks when there is a hiccup in data packets, I can't say for sure)
    Rate this comment: 12345

    dickandhowie
    08/29/2006
    Posts:1
    • HD IPTV
      Although we have the required protocols (MPEG4/H264) to minimise the bandwidth required for HDTV and we have suitable content servers and high end PCs to view it; the bit in the middle
      (the Internet) is not yet capable of supporting this.

      If it was done as multicast i.e. everyone views it at the same time when it's transmitted then those people who's ISP supported multicast (not many of these at present) would have a chance of viewing such content. If it was done on an 'on demand' basis so that you could watch what you wanted
      when you chose to i.e. as unicast transmissions, then most ISP networks would just crumple under the strain.

      I think that TV over the Internet is coming but most ISPs have a lot of of worrk to do, particularly in reducing the contention ratios that they use. These contention ratios, some as high as 50:1 were designed on the basis that all people were doing was browsing the web.

      I would say, let's see SDTV work over the Internet first then look towards HD content.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      magistral
      08/30/2006
      Posts:1
      • Re: HD IPTV
        What about all of the caching of content in proxy servers at the edges of the Internet "cloud" that Comcast, AOL, Yahoo, MSN, et al, have been doing for years, to handle just the problem you're talking about?  All of that is done via fiber optics over the Internet backbone, which is hardly running anywhere near capacity?  There are tens of terabytes/second of capacity available per optical channel today, and it's going exponentially higher every year as multiple channels are added via spectrum multiplexing (each channel is transmitted by a laser of a different "color")?  Now, if every single user on a given street is downloading something different every second of the day, that would cause increased contention, but that's not how most people behave, especially for scheduled programming (i.e., TV network style, where there is a regular production process that's fairly predictable).  The contention issue really goes away if excess overnight capacity is used to download stuff that people already are expecting to watch the next day (especially the one-offs desired by the fringe viewers with eclectic tastes).  The only content that doesn't fit that mold is breaking news and if it's of broad interest, by its very nature it's going to be cached at the edges, ready to be served as soon as it's desired to all comers, who tend to come in batches at canonical times (e.g., every half-hour) as they arrive at work, at lunchtime, coming home from work, after dinner, etc.

        All the Best,
        Joe Blow
        Rate this comment: 12345

        Joe_Blow
        09/06/2006
        Posts:1
      • Re: HD IPTV
        SDTV is here today at reeltime.com. DVD quality delivered over a grid system with minimal latency, buffering, or pixellation. If you download our player you can see the specs. It is the best quality streaming video we have found on the public internet, and it's here now.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        Michael
        09/15/2006
        Posts:1
  • HD Highest Quality Video Streaming on the Internet
    Highest Quality HD Video Streaming on the Internet


    View Instant HD Streaming at http://www.alphaexposure.com/videostreaming


    Alpha Exposure, LLC and Zero Footprint Solutions, LLC have joined forces to deliver the next generation of Internet streaming media technologies. We provide video using completely new core and enabling technologies to instantly provide streaming High Definition video up to 1080p quality to virtually any broadband user. The system is optimized to support television networks and movie rental companies moving into the online video markets in terms of quality and concurrent users. “The timing for these services is perfect”, says Robert Brim, CEO and Co-Owner of Alpha Exposure. “We are a success driven marketing company that uses advanced technology to provide value added services to a new and rapidly growing online video market”.

    Zero Footprint Solutions, LLC has developed the first and only currently existing Open Media Operating System for the Internet, which together with our unique core and enabling technologies, allows us to support instant video on demand worldwide application, data and media delivery and usage, without the need for installation of any software applications, media players or other software on the user’s computer. This allows us to instantly reach the other 72% of users who can’t or won’t download and install software to try/use a new service, with capabilities that previous downloads and installations of specialized applications and media have offered.

    Zero Footprint’s rapid deployment technologies allow us to remotely distribute virtually any application functionality and opportunity specific layout definitions to our clients, with little or no upfront infrastructure investment. Together with the efficiencies generated through Zero Footprint’s rapid development and deployment technologies, we enable transparent, fully automated private labeling and customization. This allows us to create highly scalable viral marketing opportunities without manual intervention, while simultaneously offering our clients and customers unprecedented real time micro targeted advertising possibilities to better monetize content.

    “People are looking for different types of entertainment, when and where they want to see it and we can deliver a high quality experience that meets their needs”, says Brim. To view demonstrations of advanced high quality HD streaming visit us at http://www.alphaexposure.com/videostreaming or contact us at for your HD Streaming Services at 1-417-332-0456.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Robert_Brim
    10/16/2007
    Posts:1
  • The Internet on your HDTV
    Although not quite HD, Hulu is streaming up to 480p.

    It's easy and affordable to connect the Internet to your HDTV. Just use your PC. No expensive box required.

    http://pctvcables.com
    Rate this comment: 12345

    pctvcables
    11/03/2008
    Posts:1

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review July/August 2009

Current Issue

Search Me
Inside the launch of Stephen Wolfram’s new “computational knowledge engine.”
•  Subscribe
Save 41%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
Advertisement

Follow us on Twitter

Twitter

Get Technology Review updates via the web, cellphone, or Instant Messager – Follow techreview on Twitter!

Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

Advertisement
TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.