Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

September/October 2008

Solar Boom

New twists on three leading solar technologies.

By Dean Takahashi

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

As oil prices have climbed, so has venture investment in alternative energy. According to VentureDeal, a venture-tracking service in Menlo Park, CA, solar-power startups in particular have seen a three-year surge, from a low of no venture investment in the third quarter of 2005 to a high of more than half a billion dollars in the second quarter of this year.

The most popular approach to solar power remains photovoltaic panels made from crystalline silicon. But recent years have seen the commercialization of two rival technologies: thin-film solar cells, in which layers of light-absorbing materials are deposited on glass or even flexible plastic, and solar concentrators, which conserve silicon by using mirrors or optics to focus the sun's energy onto a smaller area. With VentureDeal's help, Technology Review has identified solar startups with innovative variations on all three approaches.

CaliSolar
Most solar cells are made from very pure--and thus expensive--silicon. But ­CaliSolar can make do with silicon that has a thousand times the impurities and can cost a sixth as much. That could mean real savings, since silicon can represent a quarter to a third of the cost of making solar cells. Usually, impurities lower cells' efficiency by reabsorbing freed electrons. But CaliSolar's manufacturing process herds impurities together, so electrons are less likely to hit them. The company's cells convert 15 percent of solar energy into ­electricity, putting them in the ballpark of conventional cells.

Product: Solar cells made from "dirty" silicon

CEO: Roy Johnson

Location: Sunnyvale, CA

Funding: $13.4 million

Funders: Advanced Technology Ventures, GlobeSpan Capital Partners

URL: calisolar.com

Wakonda Technologies
Thin-film solar cells are inefficient but cheap. Where there's room to put up a lot of them, they're cost ­effective, but to compete elsewhere, they'll have to get more efficient. Wakonda has found a way to coat a metal foil with some of the most efficient photovoltaic materials known, such as gallium arsenide. The company says that its thin-film cells will be even more efficient than sili­con panels. Gallium arsenide is expensive, but Wakonda claims that its films will cost as little as its competitors'.

Product: Thin-film solar cells from superefficient semiconductors

CEO: Les Fritzemeier

Location: Fairport, NY

Funding: $9.5 million

Funders: Advanced Technology Ventures, General Catalyst Partners, Polaris Venture Partners, Applied Ventures

URL: wakondatech.com

Prism Solar Technologies

Prism has engineered a new type of solar concentrator by inscribing holograms in a transparent medium sealed between pieces of glass. Much of the light that strikes a conventional solar cell generates waste heat rather than electricity, but Prism's holograms can divert unproductive wavelengths of light away from the cell. As a consequence, it can concentrate the productive wavelengths more intensely without fear of overheating. The company claims that it can concentrate light two to three times as much as its competitors can.

Product: Holographic solar concentrators

CEO: Rick Lewandowski

Location: Lake Katrine, NY

Funding: $8.5 million

Funders: Counter Point Ventures, I2BF Venture Capital, Phoenix-Fire II, Walt Robb

URL: prismsolar.com

September/October

Would you like to read more articles from the September/October issue?

This article is from the September/October Issue of Technology Review. To read other articles from this issue simply register for My.TechnologyReview.com. It's free.

Subscribe today and save up to 41% »

Comments

  • Country Side Grid Enabled Solar Panels
    javs on 08/23/2008 at 4:50 PM
    Posts:
    68
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    Distributed solar generation that take more space but is a lot cheaper can be integrated to the country side improving the lives of many poor people if at the same time the grid offers commercial quality electricity to integrate excess output and coordinate the large savings resulting at fair prices. That is an essential element of adding the market of the Bottom of the Pyramid that has close by electrification. The EWPC article Nanosolar Breakthrough and the Old Paradigm starts by saying that "nanosolar has made great progress as it has faced and apparently surpassed many barriers so far. However, they are still facing the most important barrier, which is the old electric power paradigm centered on central generating station..." All three technologies face the same barrier in rural and also in urban areas.

    Aug 29, 2008. A comment to update this post was deleted today. The key insight is in the link to the EWPC article Let’s Avoid Many Expensive Fiascos which shows the power utilities price control business models are in a dead end and that regulators are making excessive risks that will go into customers' pockets as soon as the new investments go into infant mortality or premature obsolescence. The articles’ summary reads:

    There is no need to cite any evidence “to enable a highly competitive, pro-consumer, complete and fully functional market architecture and design paradigm shift.” What is needed is to have “the global power industry … get out of the wrong jungle to produce a EWPC based EPAct as soon as possible.”

    Three key references is the EWPC article are Warren Causey’s article Utilities Full Speed Ahead on IUE/SG: The Question is What to do First, the EWPC article Utilities and Regulators’ Value Destruction, and the EWPC article Leadership Answers What to do First.
    Rate this comment: 12345
Advertisement

Current Issue

Technology Review November/December 2008
Sun + Water = Fuel
An MIT chemist has opened the way to making hydrogen fuel from water using sunlight.
•  Subscribe
Save 41%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News

Magazine Services

Career Resources

MIT Technology Insider

Stories and breaking news from inside MIT about the latest research, innovations, and startups--in a convenient monthly e-newsletter. Subscribe today

Follow us on Twitter

Twitter

Get Technology Review updates via the web, cellphone, or Instant Messager – Follow techreview on Twitter!

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology