Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Mobile E-mail for Free

A new wireless service will provide its subscribers with e-mail at no cost for even the most basic mobile devices.

By Brittany Sauser

Monday, May 14, 2007

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

A new wireless service, which is scheduled for launch in France by the end of this month, will offer access to e-mail for free. The wireless service, called Freedom Mail, will make it possible for subscribers to view and respond to e-mail message on a cell phone or other mobile device regardless of whether or not it's a smart phone.

Credit: Technology Review

Behind the service is SetNet, a Silicon Valley-based company founded in 1993 by Nick Fodor that is the largest provider of wireless e-mail. The company currently offers its technology to service providers, who partner with cell-phone carriers. But now SetNet is taking its technology and creating its own free mail service, supported by advertisements in outgoing e-mail. The company plans to make the free service available in the United States in a few months, following its release in Europe. "Freedom Mail is for the rest of us, for those who don't have Blackberries but still use e-mail in everyday life," says Fodor, a computer programmer and the CEO of SetNet.

Currently, if a mobile-phone user wants to have e-mail connectivity through her mobile device, she must either buy a pricey data service through her carrier and have a smart phone, or the subscriber must use a carrier that is partnered with an e-mail client.

The plan for Freedom Mail comes at a time when the biggest players in the market--Research in Motion, Visto, and Microsoft--are locked in a fight over patents. In particular, Visto claims that it invented the idea of wireless electronic mail and mail synchronization. But Fodor worked on "push" e-mail services in the early 1990s, before developing his own synchronization software through Compuserv in 1993. Thus, Fodor's Freedom Mail, which uses technology that's similar to that which Visto claims to have patented, could undermine any further legal claims by Visto if the technology proves to have been developed before Visto laid down patent rights in 1999.

Story continues below


"The technology at the heart of the Visto patent is a smart caching system that SetNet has used for 10 years, and [it's] also what invalidates the patent because we have done it way before they existed," says Fodor. "Freedom Mail will liberate wireless e-mail from expensive and spurious litigation driven by very few patent owners for the sole purpose of dominating global wireless e-mail communications."

Freedom Mail will enable wireless subscribers to retrieve their current personal e-mails from Internet service providers, including Yahoo Mail, Hotmail, and Gmail, on basic cell phones. The subscriber doesn't have to go through his carrier; instead, he just sends a text message with his e-mail address to a number specific to the user's country. Freedom Mail will then confirm the e-mail address and send the subscriber back a bookmark through text. The bookmark is a URL, and when the user clicks on the URL and opens it in a browser, it marks the page. Anytime a user wants to see his e-mail account, he clicks on the bookmark, and all new e-mails will be listed.

Comments

  • Real Push Mail!
    I must say that Emoze method of pushing mail is an old method called relaying mail from your PC. So your home PC has to be on all the time to get the email and If your PC goes down bye bye email. Frankly, not in the league of real push email services like blackberry or for that matter Freedom Mail.

    Also Mr. Dulaney misses the whole point of push mail on devices. 95% of the users in this country do not have blackberry device or for that matter handsets that can handle Yahoo or google downloadable Java apps to get mail.

    His comment "The fact that they don't have a mainstream desktop e-mail user group and they are not a well-known name are strikes against them." Is not only dumb but shows a lack of understanding of the general mobile evolution of handsets and apps. This kind of thinking belongs to the Microsoft era of the early 90's
    Rate this comment: 12345

    luiss
    05/14/2007
    Posts:3
    • Re: Real Push Mail!
      My remark related to Gartner's analyst comment is that many email services and email clients came out of nowhere with no previous user base as a source(Hotmail being the best example). Consumers are not as attached to their exchange servers since they don't have any, so their loyalty to a mail client or server is not strong enough to impose any client on their phone at this point. When it comes to Exchange server and outlook clients loyalty, it was not enough to stop RIM, also coming from planet mars, to catch the mobile corporate email market by storm. So really, let's face it, making prediction in the world of wireless email for consumers is not an exercise that is easy but definitely prone to shortcomings. One major shortcoming being the lack of information on the subject. Hopefully Freedom Mail will enrich the data available to analysts to refine their predictions. The ones available from mobile carriers regarding wireless email for consumers are not available to analysts because large carriers keep their information confidential. It leaves not much to analyze I guess.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      freedomail
      05/15/2007
      Posts:2
  • interesting, but...
    what Freedom Mail is doing is interesting, but IMO wont be that useful in most cases.

    Freedom Mail requires web access. if the cell phone already has web access, then it can probably access web mail (gmail, hotmail, yahoo mail, etc) unless the browser has some limitations (javascript, etc). in this case, Freedom Mail would be simply making access easier/faster.

    now, if you had an email account that didnt have web access (which is becoming more and more rare), _then_ Freedom Mail would be useful (assuming it can access standard POP3/IMAP/etc accounts, which i'm sure it can).

    but still, this requires you to give you email password to a third party company, which IMO is a very bad idea. there's only two places where a password should be stored: in your head and on the original server, encrypted. the last thing you should be doing is giving it to some random company.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    brunascle
    05/14/2007
    Posts:68
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: interesting, but...
      Passwords are stored encrypted in your mail client but most often they are transmitted in clear over pop and sometimes imap connections on network anyone can spy with tools accessible to any script kid. All blackberry users access their pop accounts and give away their password to RIM to do it on their behalf. Also many web based email services allow to add 3rd party mailboxes and they also require users to provide their mail account passwords. So in theory you may be right but practically everything shows that the theory you expose does not translate well.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      freedomail
      05/15/2007
      Posts:2
  • The Reality of emoze
    Reading Ms. Sauser's article, we found there to be several false statements concerning emoze which we feel need to be rectified.

    "Its service gives users the option of downloading its software to their phone so that they can access the company's server"

    1st of all, when emoze users use our service to push emails to their device their emails are never routed through our servers. The function of the PC Connector is to tunnel their outlook emails, contacts, calendar and tasks via their own PC. This insures the highest security possible as NO data is stored and forwarded.

    Alternatively, for users with (OWA) emoze allows you to push your emails and data via (OWA) Outlook web access - to hundreds of mobile devices. This is also a 100% free service, removing the need for a PC Connector altogether!

    Emoze has always been and will remain a free service, not supported by any advertising. Once your emails are synced to your device you can reply and read them at any time giving you real access to your PIM anywhere.

    Freedomail Cons:
    - Being forced to put up with advertising to view your emails.
    - Necessity of web Access to view your emails, no GPRS connection, no access to your emails!
    Rate this comment: 12345

    emozeoren
    05/15/2007
    Posts:1
    • Re: The Reality of emoze
      Oh cool, so no GPRS and email from Emoze will arrive magically to the handset? But it will get to my PC right?

      PC connector is a rehash of 90's email forwarding.......next
      Rate this comment: 12345

      luiss
      05/16/2007
      Posts:3
    • Re: The Reality of emoze
      Since the publication of this article, I have recieved updated information about the Emoze service from the company. Thus, the article now reflects this information.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Brittany Sau...
      05/18/2007
      Posts:33
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • 8 years behind Japan
    NTT DoCoMo introduced cheap mobile mail with its i-mode service in Febrary 1999. By the end of 2001 more than 70% of Japanese subs had this mail.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Jeff
    05/15/2007
    Posts:3
    • Re: 8 years behind Japan
      there is a difference between real email and short messages which is what DoCoMo launched. The number of characters there was 500 vrs some 180 characters (SMS) here.

      They have 3rd party companies that operate like fredoom mail that have about 300k subscribers paying $3 per month for pulling email.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      luiss
      05/16/2007
      Posts:3
  • MeOnGo is better..
    With all due respect,freedom mail sounds like an older version of MeOnGo. An email service designed around one year ago! whats more, it has better features too, like for example,besides being free and easy to use,and allowing access to multiple email accounts, and viewing attachments,  it has SMS alerts,allows group configurations,data integrity,Secure Hash Algorithm with cryptographic hash but with a 160-bit message digest function.

    Try it for yourself at: http://www.meongo.com
    Rate this comment: 12345

    kaiketi
    06/01/2007
    Posts:1
    • Tricast Mail
      Tried a few mobile email clients, flurry mail is ok but can not beat Tricast Mail, has the best UI by far from all the ones i have tried.  Email download is very fast, found set up to be straight forward.  www.tricastmedia.com
      Rate this comment: 12345

      taylor
      07/06/2007
      Posts:1
  • Better than all of them
    Found this and you don't need to install a client. I've tried a few of these clients and there is always something that doesn't work right. Nothing beats this. They send you a text message everytime you receive an email with the sender info and a link that I click on to open the browser on my phone. It takes me straight into my inbox. I can even open attachments.
    www.meemo.com
    Rate this comment: 12345

    BillC
    07/26/2007
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
  • Renzoo is worth looking...
    With support for most of the popular webmail and POP email services, and mobile web access as only requirement, Renzoo from UK (www.renzoo.co.uk) gives you the same functionality.
    Renzoo also includes some other cool features such as SMS alerts with direct link to the important emails that can be additionally coupled with Skype presence status to automatically switch it on or off depending are you in front of your desktop or on the go.
    Another interesting feature is a email forward to the other mobile phone and support for email-to-sms gateways for sending link to new emails. Preview for attached .doc, .xls, .pdf is also included.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    vwatch
    11/25/2007
    Posts:1

Resources

Events

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Malleable Maps, Artistic Robots and Bubble Interfaces
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.