Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Driving Impulse Shopping with a Smart Cart

Supermarkets could soon turn to monitoring technology to make us buy more stuff.

By Duncan Graham-Rowe

Thursday, November 02, 2006

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

Radio frequency identification (RFID) technology may not only be useful for streamlining inventory and supply chains: it could also make shoppers swarm. A new study suggests that supermarkets could increase their revenues by using information gleaned from RFID tags to make shoppers behave like an impulse-buying collective.

A proposed system featuring smart shopping carts would monitor the contents of everyone's carts and feed information back to customers as they shop, all in an effort to boost sales. (Credit: Simon Smith)

Impulse buying currently accounts for about 40 percent of all supermarket purchases, says Ronaldo Menezes, an expert in swarm intelligence at the Florida Institute of Technology, in Melbourne, FL. But his research suggests that impulse buying could be significantly increased if information was fed back to shoppers about what others are buying.

It's an established fact that consumers are more influenced by other people's purchasing decisions than they are by discounts, says Menezes. Furthermore, it's well-known that people will flock or swarm in certain conditions, such as when a fire alarm goes off. The idea here was to exploit both of these inclinations in order to create a swarm of impulse shoppers.

The introduction of so-called smart shopping carts should make this possible. Already being used experimentally by a number of supermarkets, these carts are capable of knowing what a customer has put in them by scanning the contents for an RFID tag: a sort of wireless bar code that is being introduced in products. And some carts, such as the Shopping Buddy, developed by Cuesol, in Quincy, MA, have touch screens.

So by monitoring the contents of everyone's carts, the screens could possibly feed information back to customers as they shop. For example, a customer entering a particular aisle may be informed, via the cart's screen, that 60 percent of customers currently have a specific product from that aisle in their cart. Similarly, when the customer places an item in the cart, he or she may be notified about other products purchased by customers who bought this one.

Story continues below


Amazon and iTunes use similar tactics online, notes Herb Sorensen, CEO of the in-store consumer-research organization Sorensen Associates, in Troutdale, OR. He thinks the tactic will make sense in the physical world, as well. Sorensen Associates already uses RFID-enabled smart carts to conduct similar research on shopping behavior. (These carts, however, do not feature the screens that display information about other customers' purchases.)

So far Menezes has only carried out simulations of this swarming behavior, so it remains to be seen if the same behavior manifests in real shopping scenarios. "We are confident that our preferences are as close as you could get to a real consumer," he says.

Comments

  • What is the Mathematical equation behind the behvior
    Is there any mmathematical equation Menzes finds out behind the customers behavior? if yes? what it is?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    joe
    11/02/2006
    Posts:1
  • self-fulfilling prophecy
    If this really works, the store can lie about lots of people buying something and it will become true.
    Lying is a well-established marketing technique.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    ms
    11/02/2006
    Posts:130
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: self-fulfilling prophecy
      I agree 100%. The research carried had nothing to do with the
      ethics of sales models. You can probably raise issues
      related to ethics in most things you see in supermarkets: shelf positioning, layout of the store. 
      The reseach was an exercise on Swarm Intelligence. Similar things
      have been used in online stores. The retail case we studied
      has physical limitations that online stores don't have.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      ronaldomenez...
      11/03/2006
      Posts:5
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
  • need/want based buying behavior
    The system would affect the want based buying behavior only. What about the need based buying, where customers have to buy the things only they need either one brand or another.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    aisha
    11/03/2006
    Posts:1
    • Re: need/want based buying behavior
      It is likely that there would be some effect. We have not done anything on that area. There are publications that show that
      "planned items" are not affected too much by impulse shopping.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      ronaldomenez...
      11/03/2006
      Posts:5
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
    • Re: need/want based buying behavior
      In that case, the system can help the customer to choose the brand by supplying real time information - which one is selling more.
      for example brand A bought by 33% customers and Brand B by 10% etc
      Rate this comment: 12345

      zusmani
      11/04/2006
      Posts:1
  • Not Pleasing
    I find this use of technology offensive.  Smart shopping carts that show me information such as how much I have currently spent, the total weight of my items, and lets me locate products I'm interested in the store would be useful and appreciated (please make the interface for this easy enough to use in no more than two presses (ie - by category and product type, not brand, since most brands are mixed in the same area of a typical store aisle)). 

    But manipulating me to make impulse purchases?  And yes, my first thought also was, all they have to do then is lie about what's being sold - and what are you gonna do?  Complain?  To whom?  I'm not going to go to the store manager and tell her I find her system offensive because I suspect it's lying to me.  She will just nod and silently accuse me of being a grumpy old fart, which of course I am.   Meanwhile she will smugly note the swarms of women dashing to and fro through the store as new items are being "sold" to other customers in Aisle 2, and Aisle 5, and then Aisle 6, and then Aisle 3, etc.  I will then note that the trampled bodies should be cleared from Aisle 27, but I'm sure by then she will be ignoring me completely.

    I'm the sort of person who will resent that to a degree that science has not the instrumentation to measure.  My reaction will be to shop elsewhere, or if that is not convenient, to put wet paper towels over the "smart screen" where I find the information intrusive and/or unnecessary, or if that is not convenient then I will probably accidentally drop a sharp object(s) on the screen until it stops bothering me.  Get it?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    CatoTheElder...
    11/03/2006
    Posts:1
    • Re: Not Pleasing
      I find post like this one quite amuzing because I rarely undestand why people get so angry about research and technology. I also hope this is not a threat since in that case it
      stops being amuzing and becomes plain silly.  :)

      The problem of impulse shopping is *not* with the stores but with the customers.  If people could control themselves they would not be affected by this kind of technology. Customers need to be aware that everything they do has an effect in their lives. Yesterday, a study came out in the UK showing that each citizen appears in a camera (surveilance) as many as 300 times a day (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3225985/).
      So you are being watched get used to it! Supermarkets
      are not going to to be the exception to the case.

      Retails stores are *currently* using various tactics to make you
      buy more. What is the difference now? Is there anyone who actually believe that a 40% discount in a store is really 40%? Or that the store is *only* making 160% profit on that product?

      Our study has no privacy issues that don't exist already. The swarming idea is anonymous. We don't need to know what *you* are buying but everyone is buying.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      ronaldomenez...
      11/03/2006
      Posts:5
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
  • For those interested in more details
    I just replied to a few posts. Unfortunately I won't be able to do
    it for all the posts due to lack of time.
    I encourage anyone with spefic questions to contact us directly.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    ronaldomenez...
    11/03/2006
    Posts:5
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • No need to use this technology
    If you find this technology too intrusive you do not need to use it. I happen to shop in this Quincy Stop&Shop supermarket where they deployed the 'shopping buddy'. I am not using the gizmo.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    gabrielg01
    11/05/2006
    Posts:402
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Expect reasonable prices that don't necessitate getting a payday loan
    It is really needed for everybody to learn wise spending. The point is to buy things that needed, not those items that just wanted. With so many insane post holiday liquidation sales going on, shoppers aren't going to need a payday loan to nab the high-end merchandise they want. After this holiday season and the current sales to get rid of all the stuff they didn't sell, customers are getting used to 70 to 90% off items, and they may start to come to expect it. Retailers are afraid that this is going to become the case, as it will mean that consumers are going to expect reasonable prices that don't necessitate getting a payday loan to get two or three outfits worth of clothing. Consumers are also in the position that they may not be able to afford to pay high end prices anymore – in this modern economy, Sean John prices just don't seem reasonable to most people anymore. Check out this site if you need a http://personalmoneystore.com/moneyblog/2009/01/07/shopping-without-a-payday-loan-is-the-new-black/ payday loan or to read more about retail trends.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Harold C
    01/16/2009
    Posts:2

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

The Marcellus Shale Gas Rush
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.