Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Social Networking Hits the Genome

You will soon be able to compare your DNA with that of friends.

By Emily Singer

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

If you've ever wanted to know just exactly how much DNA you share with your ridiculously tall brother or doppelganger best friend, you'll soon be able to find out. 23andMe, a personal genomics startup in Mountain View, CA, is about to unveil a new social-networking service that allows customers to compare their DNA. The company hopes that the new offering will encourage consumers to get DNA testing, potentially creating a novel research resource in the process.

Personal profile: 23andMe, a personal genomics startup, offers genetic testing directly to consumers. The service searches an individual’s genome for genetic variants and provides analysis of her risk for specific diseases (above). The company will soon offer a social-networking tool allowing people to compare their genomes with those of family and friends.
Credit: 23andMe

"I think the idea of social networking has untapped potential," says George Church, a pioneer in genomics at Harvard Medical School in Boston and a member of 23andMe's scientific advisory board. "The idea has precedence in PatientsLikeMe, people who have been enabled to find one another by their disease. Here, people can find each other by their alleles [or genetic variations]."

23andMe is one of a number of companies that have sprung up in the past year to offer genome-wide DNA testing directly to consumers. People who order the $999 kit send in a sample of spit and, in return, receive an analysis of nearly 600,000 genetic variations linked to disease and other factors, such as ancestry, height, and eye color.

These fledgling companies have garnered both hype and criticism, with most of the controversy centered on the medical applications. Customers can learn their genetic risk, compared with the general population, of myriad diseases, including Alzheimer's, diabetes, macular degeneration, and cancer. But many scientists and physicians say that it's unclear whether the average user can truly comprehend this information, and whether knowing her genetic risk will actually improve her health.

Like its competitors, 23andMe offers information about an individual's disease risk. But it has also opted to emphasize more entertaining approaches to personal genomics, including using colorful visualization tools to look at a subject's ancestry and compare it with that of celebrities from Jesse James to Benjamin Franklin and Bono. Now, to capitalize on the boom in social networking, the company will launch a genome-sharing tool that allows people to compare their genome with those of family members, friends, and even strangers who have offered up their DNA data. "It seems like the first natural curiosity people have is, where do I come from? What are my roots?" says Linda Avey, who cofounded 23andMe with Anne Wojcicki. "The next natural [question] is, how do I compare to other people?"

Avey and Wojcicki hope that, as with traditional forms of social networking, word of the new tool will ripple through family and friends, bringing in new customers. Avey, who has shared her genome with many users, says that she has introduced people based on their haplogroups: genetic groupings representing major migration branches of the human evolutionary tree. Perhaps haplogroup inquiries will become the genomic alternative to the classic pickup line "What's your sign?" Or maybe genome-savvy geeks will create haplogroup-specific MySpace pages.

Story continues below

"This may serve a social need that seems to be out there," says Mildred Cho, a biomedical ethicist at Stanford University. "It seems to be an extension of people forming groups based on a particular disease or genealogy. But there's also some danger in overmagnifying the significance of those similarities. There is some skepticism about how meaningful this genetic information really is."

At this point, the genome-sharing tool is mostly fun. But Avey and Wojcicki say that their ultimate goal is to create a genomic database large enough to reveal scientifically and medically relevant information about its users. Those who order the genome kit can indicate whether they are willing to participate in future research studies. Those who opt in fill out surveys detailing their medical histories and specifics about particular conditions. The result will be a database of both genomic and phenotypic information, similar to that collected by government and academic institutions for research. But the difference will be that participants know (and in fact paid for) the details of their genome.

Comments

  • Scientific Dicatatorship here we come
    I find it quite amusing that Greg Feero would say "It's an intriguing idea to have a space for public participation in developing science.  The more we can engage the public in thinking about genomics, the better off we'll be in the long run in developing this new branch of medicine."

    One of my questions for Dr. Feero is "How precisely are we facilitating public participation in thinking about genomics...... by allowing them to pay to publicly post their gene pool?"

    Where exactly is the public input and discussion on the direction of this research, how access will be controlled, data ownership and its ultimate use?  Where is the moral discussion? Or, is this to be set aside for unrelenting profit motives as well as aspirations of control by the few?

    The money class is solely responsible for driving this agenda by leveraging academia, capital and commercial interests.  Is no one within this pathocracy stopping to ponder why this is the case, or where this is all headed, and how "humanity" will maintain control over the use of this extremely powerful data?

    It just amazes me to watch so many good smart people plunge forward into waters that will most likely envelop all of us for the benefit of a few.  Has everyone lost their ability to think independently?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    onepersonsop...
    03/29/2008
    Posts:2
    Avg Rating:
    4/5

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Laser-Triggered Chemical Reactions
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.